Cover Article | By Jocklyn Mundy | Photos courtesy of the Fitzgibbon Family
Windermere wasn’t just home for Evan Fitzgibbon—it was the foundation of his life’s purpose. It was here, beneath the oaks and among the lakes, that his sense of duty and faith took root. Where his unwavering dreams of serving his country were born and nurtured, shaping him into the remarkable man he would become.
The youngest child of John and Cindy Fitzgibbon, Evan, along with his sister Sophia, grew up in the heart of Windermere on Oakdale Street. As a child, Windermere provided Evan with an endless playground for adventures; his days were spent outdoors with his friends. Rooted in humble faith, John and Cindy created a traditional home that radiated love and hospitality. It was a place where the neighborhood kids gathered, where laughter echoed, and where Evan and Sophia learned the values of faith, kindness, service, and gratitude.
From as early as three years old, Evan’s mind was set; he knew he wanted to be a soldier. His name, in Irish, means “young warrior” and foreshadowed the life he would lead. As he grew, he became interested in history, particularly military leaders like Ulysses S. Grant and Robert E. Lee. In the third grade, Evan announced, “I'm going to West Point and become an Army Ranger.” That was when he started “building his resume.” Cindy recalls, “He always was the one that led us in all these things. He researched and found out what he needed to do.” With his plan set, Evan enrolled in the Civil Air Patrol — an auxiliary of the U.S. Air Force — throughout high school, he worked his way up the ranks of the program. For his outstanding leadership, he earned the Billy Mitchell Award and eventually became a commander.
Evan played football at Foundation Academy, serving as team captain during his senior year. Beyond the field, he had a deep love for hunting, fishing, and music. His musical journey began in kindergarten with piano lessons, later expanding to drums and eventually guitar—an artistic passion that became a defining part of his life.
Throughout his teen years, Evan’s resolve never wavered. He pursued his goals with discipline and focus, excelling in academics, sports, and extracurricular activities that showcased his passion for leadership and service. In 2017, his hard work paid off when he was accepted into West Point.
West Point, officially the United States Military Academy (USMA), is located on the west bank of the Hudson River in New York. Founded in 1802, it is one of the oldest service academies in the United States. Offering a rigorous education in military leadership, academics, and physical fitness, training cadets to become officers in the US Army. The academy is renowned for its emphasis on honor, discipline, and service, with its graduates playing key roles in American military history. Evan thrived in the challenging environment. He embraced the dual demands of academic excellence and intense military training, building the mental and physical resilience required of cadets.
While at West Point, music became Evan’s solace, a space where he could channel his thoughts and emotions into creativity. It transformed into a powerful outlet, leading him to compose and begin singing. His dual identity as a disciplined soldier and a free-spirited musician highlights the depth of his unique character. Evan has a collection of original songs on Spotify, shared under his verified artist name, Evan Fitzgibbon. These songs are now a cherished part of his legacy, providing a glimpse into the heart of a Warrior Poet, showcasing his artistic soul and the creativity that balanced his life of service.
When the Covid lockdowns were announced, West Point, like many institutions, temporarily shut down. Cadets were sent home, and classes moved online. While home, Evan reconnected with his high school sweetheart, Anna Fabry. Anna had also returned home from the University of Florida, where she was pursuing a nursing degree. The flames of romance quickly renewed, and their rekindled relationship flourished.
Despite the disruptions caused by Covid, Evan remained steadfast in his commitment to his education and training. He continued to excel academically and uphold the high standards expected of a West Point cadet. His perseverance paid off; Evan graduated in May 2021 from the United States Military Academy as a Second Lieutenant with a Bachelor of Science degree. Achieving his lifelong dream of becoming an officer in the U.S. Army, he pursued his ultimate ambition of serving as an Army Ranger. He was subsequently stationed at Fort Benning, Georgia, to complete further training, including the Stryker Leader Course and the Infantry Basic Officer Leader Course (IBOLC), where he served as the company commander.
L-R: Grandma Di (Dianne Fitzgibbon), John Fitzgibbon (Father), Evan Fitzgibbon, Anna Fabry (Fiancé), Cindy Fitzgibbon (Mom), Grandpa Joe (Joseph Waller)
In April of the following year, Evan proposed to Anna, the love of his life, in a picturesque setting on a dock overlooking the Butler Chain of Lakes, a place that perfectly reflected their shared love.
In June, Evan began Ranger School, a program renowned for its difficulty, where participants undergo grueling physical and mental challenges to develop the resilience, leadership, and tactical expertise required to earn the title of Army Ranger.
Tragically, on August 9, 2022, 2nd Lt. Evan Patrick Fitzgibbon lost his life during a training exercise at Yonah Mountain near Dahlonega, Georgia. Evan fully understood the risks of his profession, but his steadfast commitment to serving his country far surpassed any fear or hesitation. His faith and trust in God’s plan for his life gave him the courage to face every challenge, the strength to persevere through adversity, and the peace to follow his calling with unwavering conviction.
In a uniquely fitting honor, Evan was posthumously promoted to First Lieutenant and awarded the coveted title of Army Ranger—an uncommon recognition reserved for exceptional cases. This distinction reflects his extraordinary dedication, sacrifice, and the profound commitment he demonstrated throughout his service.
The Fitzgibbon family has long been deeply connected to Windermere, their service and relationships have made a difference to the town they love and call home. When tragedy struck, the entire community mourned alongside them, feeling the heartbreaking loss of one of their own. Evan was not only a cherished son of his family but also a favored son of Windermere, a young man whose journey embodied the pride of seeing him grow up, achieve his dreams, and dedicate his life to serving our nation.
When the day came to bring Evan home, the Fitzgibbon family made the solemn journey from the airport, escorted by the Windermere Police Department. As the procession entered the town, it was met with a moving tribute: hundreds of residents, friends, and neighbors of all ages lined Main Street, from 6th Avenue to Windermere Elementary School. Standing shoulder to shoulder, waving American flags of all sizes in a heartfelt tribute to honor Evan’s life and service. Black and gold ribbons, symbolizing the colors of West Point, adorned the trees along the route. Windermere stood united in both grief and pride, offering support to the Fitzgibbon family while paying tribute to a hero and one of our own.
Throughout his life, people were naturally drawn to Evan. His constant, warm, and approachable smile was infectious. His fun-loving spirit, combined with a sharp sense of humor, made him the kind of person everyone wanted to be around. Evan’s genuine nature and leadership qualities forged lasting friendships. These relationships, spanning from grade school to his classmates at West Point, have become a cherished part of his family’s life, bringing them comfort and joy in the wake of his loss.
Evan and Sophia Fitzgibbon
As the last two years have passed, Cindy reflects on their journey, sharing, “The pain of missing your loved one, of missing Evan—the void in our hearts and the longing for him—doesn’t diminish with time. Instead, my God grows bigger, carrying us through this life without our loved one.” Recently, their home dynamic shifted in a beautiful way. After eight years of missionary work in Honduras, Sophia returned home with daughters, Selah Renee and Andrea Stella. Now, the house resonates with the sound of children’s laughter and a renewed sense of purpose as they embrace this new chapter together, finding strength in each other’s presence.
In his 23 years, First Lieutenant Ranger Evan Patrick Fitzgibbon embodied the qualities of a warrior, a leader, and an artist. His life was marked by a sense of purpose, an unwavering commitment to service, and a deep love for those around him. From a young age, Evan demonstrated a unique blend of talents, interests, and faith that shaped his journey and guided his every step. His determination, creativity, and unshakable faith left an indelible mark on all who knew him and many who have since heard his story. Though his life was tragically brief, Evan’s legacy endures—bringing glory to God and inspiring others to live with courage, passion, and integrity, devoting themselves to purposes greater than their own.
Old Glory Returns to Windermere
As a memorial to our hero. | By Jocklyn Mundy | Photos courtesy of the Fitzgibbon Family
On January 11, the town of Windermere welcomed back a beloved piece of its history: the red, white, and blue horse statue known as “Old Glory.” A familiar landmark that stood proudly in front of the United Medical Corps building at the corner of East 6th and Main from the mid-90’s until 2021. The statue is now more than a nostalgic symbol—it has become a permanent memorial honoring the life and legacy of 1st Lt. Evan Patrick Fitzgibbon, Ranger-U.S. Army.
Old Glory was more than just a piece of art to the Fitzgibbon family, with their home close by, it was part of their daily lives and memories in Windermere. “We used to give directions by saying, ‘We live right behind the red, white, and blue horse,’” recalled Cindy Fitzgibbon. When United Medical Corps left Windermere in 2021, the iconic horse left with it. The Fitzgibbon’s and the town missed the patriotic statue.
After Evan’s passing, the town approached the Fitzgibbons about creating a permanent memorial in his honor; the family requested some time to reflect. During this time, Council Member Tom Stroup thoughtfully crafted a temporary wooden memorial that was outside the administration building.
A few months later, Cindy came across an artistic rendering of Windermere featuring Old Glory while shopping in Winter Garden. The sight of the iconic horse statue brought back a flood of memories and sparked an idea. “Just like Evan, Old Glory was patriotic and artistic,” said Cindy, “The more we talked and prayed about it, the more we knew how special it would be to have Old Glory return as a permanent memorial.” Most importantly, John and Cindy knew Evan would love it!
Evan’s favorite scripture, Proverbs 21:31—"The horse is made ready for the day of battle, but the victory belongs to the Lord"—added a profound connection to the idea. “It encapsulates his faith and trust in God,” Cindy explained.
Pam Martini, a family friend, took on the mission to locate Old Glory. Pam knew that if anyone could help, it would be Windermere's Town Clerk Dorothy Burkhalter… and she did just that. Dorothy connected Pam with Betsy, the administrative assistant for Don Dizney, owner of United Medical Corp and Old Glory. Betsy has fond memories of the days when the United Health Corp offices were in Windermere and recalled the community’s response when Old Glory was relocated: “I don’t think it was gone 10 minutes when my phone started ringing.” Betsy shared with Pam that Proverbs 21:31 was also a favorite scripture of Mr. Dizney.
When Don and Irene Dizney heard about Evan’s life and the opportunity to honor him, they were moved by Evan’s story and were eager to return Old Glory to Windermere in his honor. Not only did the Dizney family donate the statue, but they also refurbished it, ensuring it was restored to pristine condition as a fitting tribute to Evan.
In the early hours of January 11, with the streetlights still glowing, John Fitzgibbon met with the Public Works team for placement of Old Glory in its new home across the street from where it once stood. John wasn’t there as an engineer; he was there as a father. It was a quiet and heartfelt act of love, honoring his son.
Later that morning a crowd gathered under overcast skies to pay tribute to Evan and support the Fitzgibbon family. Despite the weather, hundreds attended, including Evan’s parents, John and Cindy, his grandfather, his sister Sophia, his nieces Selah and Andrea, and his fiancée, Anna. Don and Irene Dizney, along with other members of the Dizney family, were also present. Windermere Mayor Jim O’Brien shared heartfelt words, as did John and Cindy. Family Church Community Pastor Ray Lloyd sang and offered the invocation.
“It’s as beautiful as I remember,” said Cindy of the statue. “But now it carries a new meaning for our family—one of honoring Evan and his life’s legacy, and one of how God has used this community to connect love and kindness in people’s hearts and stories.”
John expressed his family’s profound gratitude to everyone involved in the project, especially the Dizney family, whose generosity made it possible.
The Dizney and Fitzgibbon Families at Evan’s Memorial
Old Glory’s return is more than a memorial—it is a symbol of a warrior’s heart and a life defined by faith, purpose, and service. Proverbs 21:31 reflects Evan’s journey—a warrior preparing with courage and discipline while trusting in God’s ultimate plan.
Standing once more in Windermere, Old Glory honors the legacy of Windermere’s son and hero, a young man whose unwavering faith and dedication continues to inspire. It is a testament to the strength of a community united in love, ensuring Evan’s story will live on for generations to come.
